American Gods: Season 3 Finale Review – “Tears of the Wrath-Bearing Tree” – IGN

This is a review of American Gods Season 3 finale, which premiered on Starz on March 21. Warning, spoilers below.

American Gods has all the parts to create a richly layered story. Visually stunning, well-cast, with nuanced dissections of American culture and what does or does not make something deified at its heart. And yet the sum of its parts just feels lacking. There’s a hollowness behind the stunning visuals, a blandness to the dialogue that leaves you wanting something far more daring, and musical cues that can often make one a little cringe-y. It gets close to the mark, but still misses really nailing the point, smoothing over-complicated story matters with twisty visual stimuli and allusion rather than really standing for anything at its core.

What’s Your Favorite Horror TV Series?

The Walking Dead

The Haunting of Hill House

Swamp Thing

American Horror Story

Penny Dreadful

Supernatural

Channel Zero

The Terror

Focusing so much on the journey of Shadow Moon this season has ultimately weakened the beautiful patchwork quilt this story could ultimately be. A shame, considering we’ve reached the story’s major climax (Czernobog orgasm jokes aside).

It sort of breaks the heart to write this as a fan of the source material and so many people involved. The episode is—for all intents and purposes—ultimately fine, but having read the Neil Gaiman novel and loved the first season, there’s a longing for what American Gods could have really been that you feel in every decision it makes, especially during such a crucial point in the story. In the season three finale, Shadow Moon has finally made it to the World Tree at the heart of America, to hold vigil for his dead father, Wednesday/Odin. He knows Laura has killed Wednesday and lets her go despite Norse code. She connects with Bilquis as Shadow straps himself into the tree for nine days and nights of hell. In the end, that’s all that really happens until both Wednesday and Shadow Moon’s dead bodies disappear. A literal storm starts brewing at the end.

Revelations unfold: Technical Boy is more than he seems, and so is Mr. World—to an extent. Perhaps the most crushing blow of all is that of Shadow coming to understand that this vigil was actually something of a ruse to make Odin return to his most all-powerful form. Betrayal has a way of changing things, and the finale certainly sets up an interesting “what’s to come.” Whether or not it will be able to pull that off is another thing entirely.

American Gods: Season 3 Photos

There’s a level of that Tyra Banks “we were all rooting for you!” meme-ified emotion going on in this review. Maybe one can care too much and be unable to just take this finale and this iteration of the tale for what it is and detach it from the history one has with the story. But from a viewer standpoint, it all just feels a bit slapdash and ultimately missing the heart of the story that was set up in its complicated and beautiful first season. Without the fury of someone like Orlando Jones’ Mr. Nancy, the love of the Jinn and Salim, and all the other little tales woven throughout Gaiman’s original story, American Gods doesn’t feel like it’s getting at the full scope of America and what drives it.

And that—especially as a viewer in 2021—is a very frustrating thing. Perhaps for more casual fans of the story, this suffices, but with a story this complicated, is there really such a thing? Only time and the number of people still watching (how poetic), will tell us this.

Loading

Play